Our Friends

Beloved Grizzly Bear 399 and cubs, one of which was recently shot and killed.

Beloved Grizzly Bear 399 and cubs, one of which was recently shot and killed.

Rate this article:

Printer friendly view Send to a friend

Controversial Grizzly Bear Death A Family Tragedy

An Obituary For Bear 615

Written by Todd Wilkinson (Authors Bio)

(EDITOR'S NOTE:  Animals cannot write their own death notices, so consider this an obituary submitted on behalf of a mother, Grizzly Bear 399, who became famous in Jackson Hole, Wyoming for raising her three cubs along the roadside of Grand Teton National Park.  Read the story about the bear family, titled The Saga of 399, in Jackson Hole Magazine.  Also by clicking here read Wildlife Art Journal's story about the photographer, Cal McKitrick, who took the bear family's picture above). And for an update on DNA testing, click here .


Grizzly Bear 615 (2006-2009):  An Obituary

Grizzly Bear 615, a lifelong resident of Jackson Hole, was slain September 19, 2009 near Ditch Creek in the Bridger-Teton National Forest.

Countless human admirers in Wyoming and around the world are now mourning her death. DNA analysis is being conducted to confirm her family lineage, but the female bruin is believed to be the offspring of a famous matriarch.

Cal McKitrick shared his famous photo:  What is missing?
Cal McKitrick shared his famous photo: What is missing?
615, the numeric identity given her by wildlife researchers, was born inside her natal den somewhere in the vicinity of northern Jackson Hole during the winter of 2006.  She was one of three triplets delivered solo by her healthy photogenic mother, Bear 399.

Under 399’s protective nurturing, 615 and siblings spent their juvenile years growing up in Grand Teton National Park and the adjacent national forest, learning how to survive in a landscape traversed by lots of people, some filled with hatred toward her species.

399 frequented national park roadsides because they gave her access to natural foods and afforded security from territorial male grizzlies that might do harm to her young.

The presence of 399’s clan created a sensation. Tourists traveled great distances (and spent a lot of money) to see the bears in their native habitat inside a national park. Since the 1970s, the Yellowstone ecosystem population of grizzlies, to which this family belonged, was classified as threatened and given protection under the U.S. Endangered Species Act.

It is no exaggeration that tens of thousands of park visitors, especially residents of this valley, were captivated. The foursome was featured on the cover of Jackson Hole Magazine in 2008.

According to those who studied and celebrated her, including local wildlife photographers Thomas Mangelsen and Diana Stratton, 399 was an attentive mother skilled in avoiding people.

But for one incident in 2007, in which 399 mauled a Grand Teton Park hiker who accidentally startled the bear family as it was feeding on an elk, there was no indication the bruins harbored malice toward people.  Indeed, the mauled hiker pleaded with rangers not to destroy the bears.

615 followed in her mother’s paw prints after she was left to fend for herself in spring 2008.  She demonstrated prowess in hunting and scavenging sustenance the way she was taught; she minded her own business and kept her distance from humans.

On the day she died, at around 11 a.m., 615 was eating a moose carcass left behind by a hunter near Ditch Creek north of the tiny town of Kelly.

The man who illegally shot her was retrieving the meat of a deer that had been harvested earlier.  He told authorities he knew of the moose carcass, upon which 615 fed, yet apparently did not cut a wider path to avoid it.

615 was fired upon from a distance of nearly half a footfall field. Except for perking her ears and rising briefly on her hind legs to observe the human who invaded her comfort zone, she showed no signs that she intended to attack. Her killer admitted to investigators that she was 40 yards away when he pulled the trigger.

Carrying bear pepper spray, a scientifically proven non-lethal tool, is required of hunters in Grand Teton Park, but, inexplicably, the Bridger-Teton National Forest does not mandate it. The shooter cited for killing 615 toted a .270-caliber rifle and a .44-caliber handgun.

The first bullet to strike 615 penetrated her chest and exited her abdomen, essentially creating a gut shot that failed to kill her. Whirling in pain, 615 was shot a second time on the left side of her body.  She died on the spot.

The shooter told authorities 615 “had taken several steps toward him” yet she fell five feet from the place where she had been feeding.

It is span of separation between man and bear that one prominent grizzly researcher told this obituary writer falls far short of meeting the rationale for killing a grizzly in self defense based upon “allegedly being in imminent fear for one’s life.”

Bear 615 leaves behind a large group of people who became passionate advocates for her survival. She is not the only grizzly to inhabit Jackson Hole but she is the 20th grizzly known to have died already this year in the ecosystem from encounters with humans.

Some have said the shooter of 615 was justified no matter what circumstances led to her death.  "A dead bear is better than a dead human," they say.  However, the very same logic which gives the human, Stephen Westmoreland, the benefit of doubt and proclaims him innocent until proven guilty for illegally taking a grizzly, can also be applied to Bear 615. In numerous instances this summer, the same bear was observed in close proximity to people who were invading her space and she did not charge.

Indeed, there have been plenty of responsible hunters in the general vicinity of the moose carcass and who downed other animals, gutting and harvesting the meat, who had no negative encounter with 615, let alone seeing her.

If the implication is: That any person carrying a gun who encounters a grizzly that stands up, flares its ears and drops to all fours half of a football field away, interprets the behavior as aggressive and therefore feels justified in pulling the trigger, there are going to be a lot of dead and wounded grizzly bears. Fortunately, many hunters already have not invoked similar reasoning. But now the autumn hunting season in Grand Teton National Park is just beginning, a season that was grandfathered into existence in 1950 when the park was created and designed to help control large numbers of elk.

Bear 615's death is a shame not solely because she was popular with humans, but as a female approaching the prime of breeding age who learned and practiced behavior that generally kept her away from people, she is the kind of large meat-eating animal managers want to aggressively protect, be it a grizzly, lion, or tiger.

Just as her life made her a beloved poster child for being a “good grizzly,” now, in death, she is a powerful symbol as Exhibit A, showing why it is the chronic inability of Homo sapiens to exercise sound judgment and self control in their actions that raises questions about the future of this special bear population.

Rate this article:

Printer friendly view Send to a friend

header_discussion-blog

Indeed Murderer

Posted By Aphoto4you on Oct 22, 2009
I have it also posted on my website....aphoto4you.com
I have observed this bear for 3 years and her family...I reside part time in Jackson Hole....aprox 6 mo... and i followed this family for a while...

It is shame...
It is sad..

Thank you Todd.

Posted By Shane on Oct 21, 2009
Thank you Todd for the well thought out and appropriate answer. I was by no means addressing you with more than a caution about lumping all "homo spaiens" in the same category. The rest of the comments were addressed to those who use word like "murder," "persecution," "kill baby Kill," etc.. Murder speakes of premeditation and rage, persecution speaks of an inherrant dislike and intentionalality toward harm, "kill baby kill" sounds like gleeful killing. This foolish hunter broke a lot of rules of the backcountry and bear country, and in the end he shamefully shot a bear out of fear for his life which he himself put in jeapardy. What he did was pure foolishness. But haven't we all made a mistake and done something foolish. How many of us have foolishly pulled out in front of someone and nearly caused an accident. That accident could have caused someone's death. Would that give you the title of "murderer," or would people think you have a "Kill Baby Kill" menatlity, were you "persecuting" the one you hit. No, it was a foolish mistake. In the event of an accident you would be in trouble with the law. This man is in trouble with the law as well. If he gets a slap on the wrist, don't blame him. Contact the local law enforcement and share your displeasure. Let them know what the public sentiment is about such unwise acts.
In this age of energy conservation, let's use our energies wisely and instead of wasting energy railing against a fool, why don't we act on our convictions to support bear country education, hunter education, grizzly bear research. Lets use our enegry and our words to build up, or edify, rather than waste them in hurtful destruction.
Enough said on my part.

From Todd Wilkinson, Editor

Posted By Todd Wilkinson on Oct 21, 2009
Dear Shane, I thank you and everyone else for commenting. I think your last observation, especially, is worth heeding: "We have so many bears now because of our ability [to] judge and care for those animals. There are way more of us out in the woods who see bears and interact with them in a positive way than those have have foolishly killed them."

Indeed. I couldn't agree more, to a point. The death of Bear 615 is a cautionary tale and I make clear in my blog that there are plenty of hunters out there who behave responsibly (as well as tens of thousands of hikers in grizzly country who do not carry weapons and are traversing through areas with bears and who never have a negative encounter). I don't know how old you are, but I remember vividly seeing posters in Yellowstone back in 1983 (when I worked in the national park as a summer employee). The posters announced a series of meetings on the troubling decline of grizzlies in the ecosystem. The bear population was in a free-fall. Human behaviors—leaving trash around that created habituated bears; hunters having loose trigger fingers; and habitat destruction—were the prime culprits. There certainly are MORE bears today than there were THEN, perhaps three times as many, (maybe a total of 600 or 650) in a region covering 20 million acres. Really, that's not many bears over an ares that would cover a huge chunk of, say, New England.

It doesn't take many years of losing females of breeding age or entering breeding age to turn what has been a stable, or modestly growing bear population into one moving into decline. The loss of carnivores is a huge problem worldwide.

I have been within closer proximity to grizzlies in Yellowstone and Alaska (and wild lions on foot in Africa) than the shooter of 615 was, each time unarmed.

I, too, have been a hunter and there are places where I do not go grouse hunting in the mountains because I do not want to run into a grizzly. That's my choice, not a judgment of other hunters. My blog posting was not a condemnation of hunting and in fact I praise hunters who keep their cool and take every precaution they can to avoid having to kill a bear. Stephen Westmoreland, the hunter who shot 615, made a series of personal decisions that led to his bear encounter and resulted in him pulling the trigger. Those decisions also led to him being cited by investigators for killing the bear. He chose to walk close to a moose carcass in an area where he knew grizzlies lived...a practice the Wyoming Game and Fish Department in a recent advisory said was human behavior that should be avoided.

In addition, Bear 615 had been seen by countless hikers during the summer and never once exhibited aggressive behavior. You, nobly, have had plenty of bear encounters yourself and did not have to use bear spray or bullets.

One more fact worth noting: Routinely, I have conversations with members of the Yellowstone Grizzly Bear Study Team, the federal research unit that has tracked grizzlies for decades. In thousands of encounters with bears in the backcountry, those field biologists have not felt the need to kill bears and they say that bear spray works.

You are right: We were not there when Westmoreland pulled the trigger. I will say this again: We are going to have a lot more dead bears if vague expressions of fear become a valid justification killing carnivores. That's precisely one of the excuses given by settlers for nearly wiping out grizzlies and wolves. I am willing to bet that with you being an outfitter, one of the things your clients enjoy about going out in the wilderness with you is the untamed unpredictability and atmosphere of wildness you offer. Fear and wonder go with the territory when you enter grizzly country. It's part of the magic. Thanks again for writing.



There are 8 more comments for this article See All Comments >

Leave your comment

Your e-mail address will not be publicly displayed, but is required. We respect your privacy and
never send spam. Read our privacy policy for details...
Your Name*:
* = required fields
eMail Address *:
Comment Headline*:
What is your comment?*

Hard to read? See a new code.
Please type the letters you see in the image above. This helps us to prevent spam submissions.
Enter code here:

Already a subscriber? Log-in here.

LOG-IN HERE
Lost Your Password?

Recently Tweeted

Our final two cover candidates are this ostrich piece by James Stroud and George McLean's, below http://t.co/oA8UiFHD

Facebook

Receive our free articles by email

Sign up now and we'll send you a free monthly newsletter that reminds you of important stories in Wildlife Art Journal, blogs and other content you'll want to know about.

First Name:

Email Address:

Yes, please let me know about special subscription savings.